Christian Science explains…
AUTHOR: Branch, Rick
PUBLISHED ON: April 25, 2003

                  Christian Science explains…

              Jesus Never Died For No One Sinned!

                          Rick Branch

                          Arlington, TX

The entire Old Testament pointed forward toward the coming
messiah.  The Gospels document the fact that Jesus was that
expected messiah.  The remainder of the New Testament points back
to the finished work of the messiah.

The pinnacle of Jesus’ work can be summarized with the words,
death, burial and resurrection.

However, according to Mary Baker Eddy, founder of the First
Church of Christ, Scientist, commonly known as Christian Science,
Jesus could not die for Man’s sins, because Mankind never sinned!

Despite the fact that the Bible is explicit about Man’s sinful
nature, that Jesus came to save Man from sin by becoming the
sacrifice for man and that this saving process involved the
death, burial and resurrection of Jesus, Christian Science
explains this is an error – or at the very least – Man’s
interpretation on these events are in error.

According to one of Eddy’s many writing, “She affirmed that the
Scriptures cannot properly be interpreted in a literal way.  The
truths they teach must be spiritually discerned, before their
message can be borne fully to our minds and hearts.

“That there is a dual meaning to every Biblical passage, the most
eminent divines of the world have concluded; and to get at the
highest, or metaphysical, it is necessary rightly to read what
the inspired writers left for our spiritual instruction.

“The literal rendering of the Scriptures make them nothing
valuable, but often is the foundation of unbelief and
hopelessness.  The metaphysical rendering is health and peace and
hope for all.

“The literal or material reading is the reading of the carnal
mind, which is enmity toward God, Spirit” (Miscellaneous
Writings, p. 169).

Thus, to Eddy, reading the Bible in a literal style is to read it
with the carnal mind, to read error into its meaning.  According
to Eddy’s preferred style, the metaphysical style, sin does not
mean sin, death does not mean death and resurrection does not
mean resurrection.

What then, according to Christian Science do these terms mean?
How should people understand the Bible?  What was Jesus ultimate

                        Sin Is Not Sin

The idea that sin is not real may sound new to some, but Eddy
explains that the idea did not originate with her.

She writes, “What is the cardinal point of difference in my
metaphysical system?  This: that by knowing the unreality of
disease, sin and death, you demonstrate the allness of God.  This
difference wholly separates my system from all other.

“The reality of these so-called existences I deny, because they
are not to be found in God, and this system is built on Him as
the sole cause.  It would be difficult to name any previous
teachers, save Jesus and his apostles, who have thus taught”
(Unity of God, p. 9-10).

Hence, the idea that sin and death are unreal did not originate
with Mary Baker Eddy, but rather, according to Eddy, with Jesus
and His apostles.

Since sin is unreal, then according to Christian Science
reasoning, “Man is incapable of sin…” (Science and Health: With
Key to the Scriptures, p. 475).

If man is incapable of sin then how does one avoid the sin that
seems to be happening in everyday life?  According to Eddy, sin
or the appearance of sin can be avoided by denying its reality.

“To get rid of sin through Science, is to divest sin of any
supposed mind or reality, and never to admit that sin can have
intelligence or power, pain or pleasure.  You conquer error by
denying its verity” (Ibid, p. 339).

Simply stated, sin is non-existent.  However, if one believes sin
exists and wishes to stop sinning, then merely stop believing in
the existence of sin.  If sin’s reality is denied, then sin
ceases to exist.

If there is no sin and man is therefore incapable of committing
that which does not exist, then why does the Bible speak of Jesus
dying in order to bring about man’s atonement from sin?

                  Jesus Saving Action For Man

Keeping in mind the fact that according to Christian Science, Man
is incapable of sin for sin is unreal, then Jesus’ part in the
redemption of mankind acquires an extremely unique

Remember also that according to Eddy, the Bible is to be
interpreted spiritually or metaphysically, not literally or with
the carnal mind.

With all of this in mind, Eddy writes in her book Miscellaneous
Writings in the question and answer section, “If there is no sin,
why did Jesus come to save sinners?”

Having asked the question, Eddy then answers, “Jesus came to seek
and to save such as believe in the reality of the unreal; to save
them from this false belief; that they might lay hold of eternal
Life, the great reality that concerns man, and understand the
final fact, – that God is omnipotent and omnipresent…” (p. 63).

Jesus came to save mankind from the false belief that sin is

“Our Master bore the cross to show his power over death; then
relinquished his earth-task of teaching and demonstrating the
nothingness of sickness, sin and death, and rose to his native
estate, man’s indestructible eternal life in God” (Ibid, p. 64).

Jesus saving work was to exemplify the fact that death is unreal,
that sin is only an illusion or false belief and that to deny
their existence is the ultimate task of each person.

            A Different Work From A Different Jesus

The teaching that Jesus went to the cross to demonstrate that
“…the only reality of sin, sickness, or death is the awful fact
that unrealities seem real to human, erring belief, until God
strips off their disguise” is central to Christian Science
theology (Science and Health, p. 472).

This idea is so foreign to biblical Christianity that it is not
surprising to find that Christian Science not only teaches a
faulty reason why Jesus came, but also believes in an erroneous

According to Eddy, “Jesus is the name of the man who, more than
all other men, has presented Christ, the true idea of God,
healing the sick and the sinning and destroying the power of
death.  Jesus is the human man, and Christ is the divine idea;
hence the duality of Jesus the Christ” (Ibid, p. 473).

The Jesus of Christian Science was a man who possessed the Christ
consciousness, who demonstrated the falseness of sin and the path
for escaping sins influence – deny its reality.

The apostle Paul warns Christians to be wary of those who would
come preaching “another Jesus” (II Corinthians 11:4).  Christian
Science would certainly fall within the bounds of this warning.

                    The Cross And Jesus Death

Similar to the Christian Science idea that sin is an illusion,
they also teach that “there is no death” (The First Church of
Christ Scientist and Miscellany, p. 300).

If there is no death then what of the cross?  Remembering the
“duality of Jesus the Christ” as taught by Eddy, her comments in
Christ and Christmas will make sense.

She states, “Christ was not crucified – that doom was Jesus’
part” (p. 21).  Jesus, being the man who possessed the Christ
consciousness, was the one who went to the cross and who appeared
to die.

However, because “Life is real, and death is the illusion”, Jesus
could therefore not die (Science and Health, p. 428).

As Eddy explained, “His disciples believed Jesus to be dead while
he was hidden in the sepulchre, whereas he was alive,
demonstrating within the narrow tomb the power of Spirit to
overrule mortal, material sense” (Ibid, p. 44).

Thus, when the Bible appears to say that Jesus died on the cross
and His body was laid in the tomb, it must be understood,
according to Christian Science theology, that Jesus actually
never died but was rather in the tomb denying deaths reality.

If the death Jesus appeared to suffer for the sins that man
cannot commit is in reality a misunderstanding of biblical
teachings, then what of the resurrection?

                Jesus Resurrected from Non-Death

It is obvious that if Jesus never died on the cross to atone for
sins that mankind cannot commit, than the resurrection must have
a unique meaning in Christian Science too.

After finishing a brief section on the unreality of sin and
death, Eddy then turns to the resurrection of Jesus.

She explains, “When Jesus reproduced his body after its burial,
he revealed the myth or material falsity of evil; its
powerlessness to destroy good and the omnipotence of the Mind
that knows this: he also showed forth the error of nothingness of
supposed life in matter, and the great somethingness of the good
we possess, which is of Spirit, and immortal” (Miscellaneous
Writings, p. 201).

Jesus resurrection was thus the manifestation of the error of
evil.  He demonstrated that sin and death are illusions and that
if one wishes to rid themselves of these illusions they only need
to deny their reality.

In a chapter titled “Is there no death”, Eddy confirms her
twisted metaphysical theology by declaring, “Resurrection from
the dead (that is, from the belief in death) must come to all
sooner or later; and they who have part in this resurrection are
they upon whom the second death has no power.

“All life is Spirit, and Spirit can never dwell in its
antagonist, matter.  Life, therefore is deathless, because God
cannot be the opposite of Himself.

“In Christian Science there is no matter; hence matter neither
lives nor dies” (Unity of Good, p. 41).

Thus, in the final analysis, Jesus, who possessed the Christ
consciousness as do all men to a lesser extent, went to the
cross, not to bring about forgiveness of sin, for sin is an
illusion, but rather to demonstrate that death is an illusion.

On the morning of the resurrection, the supposed physical body of
Jesus was reproduced in its original illusionary form, for all
matter is illusion, and thereby demonstrated to mankind that all
could do the same by denying the reality of sin and death.

º                                                                        º
º  This file passed through Abba II, where Christians find fellowship,  º
º  Information and Resources, and where non-christians can find honest,  º
º  reasonable answers about what (and why) Christians believe.          º
º                                                                        º
º  ÄÄÄÄÄÄÄ  All information can be downloaded OR read on-line ÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄ  º
º                                                                        º
º  þ Unique, Christian Files            þ Bible Studies and Discussions    º
º  þ Abba II’s Christian Magazine      þ Ministry Newsletters          º
º  þ News of Interest to Christians    þ Christian Directory            º
º  þ Specializing in Apologetics        þ Christian Events Calendar      º
º                                                                        º

Doc Viewed 14848 times

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating / 5. Vote count:

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.